By the end of this article, you will be able to compare three ways a customer already solves a problem, separate observations from guesses and choose one small next test. You can begin with public information and a notebook. No paid research report is required.

The first question is about the customer

A market is the people with a particular need and the offers competing to meet it. A competitor is an alternative that a customer might choose instead of yours. It may look much like your business or solve the same problem in a different way. Researching alternatives helps you see what people can already do, what they may still find difficult and where your business might fit (Business.gov.uk, no date).

You do not have to “beat” every other business. You need to understand what choice the customer faces. Even a business with a new product has competitors in this broad sense: people can continue with their current habit, do a task themselves or spend their time and money elsewhere.

Throughout this article, Maya's Lunch Box is fictional. It is considering preordered lunches for workers near a station. A café serving lunch nearby is a direct competitor because it offers a similar solution. A supermarket meal deal is another plausible choice, even if its service model differs. A worker who brings food from home uses a substitute: a different way to meet the same need. None of these examples is a statement about a particular real station or shop.

If Maya were to say “There is no other preorder lunch business on this street,” she would still need to ask what someone does when they do not buy her lunch. A narrow search for identical products can miss the customer's real alternatives.

Decide what you are comparing

Start with the customer's job, not your product category. Maya might write: “Get a suitable lunch during a short work break.” That phrasing helps her notice cafés, supermarkets, packed lunches, delivery and perhaps skipping lunch. She does not have to study every possible choice. She should select a few that her intended customers actually consider.

A useful first comparison asks:

  • What does the customer get? Look beyond a brand name to the meal, collection or delivery experience.
  • What does it cost them? Money, time and effort can all matter. Do not invent a rival's current prices.
  • How easy is it to obtain? Opening hours, location, ordering and waiting can matter more than an extra feature.
  • What information is available before the decision? Can a person see price, suitability, availability and how to get help?
  • What is still unknown? A website cannot tell Maya why a particular worker chooses it.
Business.gov.uk recommends examining competitors' prices, promotion, delivery and points of difference, using both a customer's viewpoint and desk research (Business.gov.uk, no date). Desk research means learning from information that already exists, such as public menus and websites. It is useful, but it does not replace talking to potential customers about their own choices.

Make a small evidence table

image
Table 1
For each real observation, write the source and date: “Public menu on the café website, checked 27 September 2026,” for example. A public menu tells you what the business advertises; it may not tell you what is available at noon. If you note “the café lists collection,” that is an observation. “All workers prefer collection” is an unsupported interpretation. Keep the two apart.

Online reviews can point to questions worth asking, but one review is one person's report in a particular context. Do not present it as a representative survey. If you visit a business as a customer, behave normally and record only what you can fairly observe. You do not need to obtain a competitor's private plans or another customer's personal information.

The simplest three-column note

When a large table feels like too much, use Observed / Possible meaning / Next check:

  • Observed: The public page does not state a collection time.
  • Possible meaning: A new customer might feel uncertain about waiting.
  • Next check: Ask potential customers whether knowing a collection time affects how they choose lunch.
The observation alone does not prove an opportunity. Maya's interpretation becomes useful when she tests it. This habit protects you from turning your own preference into a claim about the whole market.

What if there are many competitors?

Choose three that represent different options: one close rival, one different kind of provider and one substitute or current habit. Record why you selected them. If you later find customers use other options, update the comparison. You are making a working map, not claiming an exhaustive industry census.

Direct competition means similar offers for the same customer need. Indirect competition means a different offer competes for that need or budget. A substitute is a different way to get the underlying job done. The boundaries depend on the question. A café may be direct when Maya compares lunches, while bringing food from home is a substitute. Labels are less important than accurately describing the customer's choices.

Do not infer that many competitors mean “no room” or that few competitors mean “easy success”. The number of visible providers does not tell you enough about customer demand, costs, service quality or barriers. The next steps are to understand why customers choose as they do and whether you can deliver something they value.

SWOT: organise what is inside and outside your business

SWOT stands for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats. Strengths and weaknesses are about your own organisation and its resources; opportunities and threats come from the environment around it (Gomez Albrecht, Green and Hoffman, 2023b).

For Maya, a possible strength could be a limited menu she can prepare consistently. A possible weakness could be small lunchtime capacity. An opportunity to investigate might be interest in collecting a preordered lunch. A possible threat could be a new local offer or higher ingredient costs. None of these is a verified finding about a real business.

Avoid writing “our competitor has high prices” under your own strength. That is an external observation, if verified, and may create an opportunity; your strength would be what you can reliably provide. Similarly, “we have low brand awareness” describes your position, but it should lead to a specific question or action rather than fill a box for its own sake.

A useful SWOT note ends with a decision: “Because our capacity is limited, we will test one small collection slot before promoting a full-day service.” The letters are a way of organising evidence. Filling four boxes does not validate the business. Dhruvi's existing SWOT Analysis explains the framework at greater depth; this paragraph gives you what you need to use it here.

PESTLE: notice wider changes

PESTLE is a prompt for six external influences: Political, Economic, Social, Technological, Legal and Environmental. It helps you consider changes outside your own business that could affect decisions (Gomez Albrecht, Green and Hoffman, 2023a). You do not have to write a paragraph under every letter.

Maya could ask whether customers' lunch budgets are changing (economic), whether working patterns alter lunchtime footfall (social), or whether a new way of ordering matters to the people she serves (technological). A legal question might concern rules that apply to a proposed food business; Maya would consult current official guidance before operating. An environmental question could concern packaging and waste. A political issue would matter if a relevant public decision changed the conditions for her business.

These are questions, not claims that such changes have occurred. Record a relevant source and date. If you cannot see how a broad trend affects the specific customer or offer, leave it aside for now. Do not use PESTLE as a reason to copy old statistics into a current article.

Five Forces: look beyond the businesses you can see

Michael Porter's Five Forces framework asks how competition works across an industry. The five are rivalry among existing firms, threat of new entrants, threat of substitutes, bargaining power of buyers and bargaining power of suppliers (Harvard Business School Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness, no date; Porter, 2008). The word power means the ability to influence terms such as price, quality or supply. The framework concerns market structure and the division of value, not whether a rival is a good or bad person.

Rivalry: how strongly do similar sellers compete?

Maya can observe how many nearby lunch providers might serve the same workers, what each offers and how customers distinguish them. A busy street does not by itself show whether the providers are profitable. She should avoid turning a quick walk into a confident market-size estimate.

New entrants: how easy is it for another seller to begin?

If someone else can enter quickly with a similar offer, Maya may find it difficult to rely on a feature that is easy to copy. The answer depends on real costs, capabilities, locations and applicable requirements. Do not assume an online ordering form is a permanent barrier to entry.

Substitutes: what different solution could replace the purchase?

A packed lunch is the clearest example here. If workers already prefer it for cost, dietary or planning reasons, a clearer menu alone may not change their choice. Maya needs to learn what matters to the people she hopes to serve.

Buyer power: how easily can customers choose differently?

A worker may have several nearby options and little cost in switching. That can make price, suitability and reliability especially important. “Power” does not mean the customer controls the business; it means their alternatives affect the terms Maya can offer.

Supplier power: who provides what Maya needs?

If Maya depends on one source for an essential ingredient or packaging item, a supply change could affect her costs or promised menu. She can explore alternatives and keep her offer realistic. Do not assert that any particular supplier has power without knowing the actual situation.

Five Forces can be valuable when a big decision depends on the shape of a market. For a first small test, Maya may only need to notice the strongest question: perhaps substitutes and collection convenience. The Harvard Business School framework page gives the original five-force structure; Porter's article offers deeper reading (Porter, 2008).

How the three tools work together

The three frameworks ask different questions. PESTLE scans broad changes outside the business. Five Forces asks how an industry distributes pressure and value among buyers, suppliers, entrants, substitutes and rivals. SWOT summarises what those external findings may mean alongside the business's own strengths and weaknesses. They should help a decision, not create three repetitive essays.

For Maya, the sequence might be: workers have a short break (customer situation); local alternatives and packed lunches exist (market comparison); limited kitchen capacity is an internal weakness (SWOT); possible ingredient cost change needs checking (PESTLE); packed lunches are a substitute (Five Forces). Her practical decision is to test a small preorder slot and ask people what they need to know before trying it. Every link in this reasoning is provisional until she gathers evidence.

A strategic trade-off means choosing one use of time or money over another. Maya could spend two hours refining a limited collection process instead of building multiple social profiles. If tests show price matters more than timing, she should reconsider that choice. A tool is useful only if it changes what she investigates or does next.

Try it: a fifteen-minute competitor map

Use your own business idea or Maya's fictional example.

  1. Complete: “My customer wants to ___.” Phrase the need without using your product name.
  2. Write three alternatives: a close rival, a different provider and a substitute or current habit. If you use real businesses, note each source and date.
  3. For each alternative, record what it offers, what it might cost in money/time/effort, and what you still do not know. Write “not checked” instead of inventing a price or rating.
  4. Ask one SWOT question about your own capability. Ask one PESTLE question about a wider change. Ask which of Porter's forces might matter most. You do not have to fill all the headings.
  5. Write one possible opportunity, one risk and one action you can take this week. State what result would make you change your mind.
A useful answer includes a substitute, distinguishes fact from assumption and finishes with a feasible next check. For Maya, it could be “Ask three workers how they normally get lunch and what information they need before trying a preorder.” Three conversations are an exploratory exercise, not a representative sample. She would note the answers without turning them into a claim about all workers.

Common mistakes and a short check

“I have no competitors.” People may already solve the problem by doing it themselves, using a different service or going without.

“The rival's old website means customers dislike them.” That is an interpretation. Ask customers what matters and observe what the business actually offers.

“The cheapest price wins.” A customer may also value suitability, time, service or trust. Compare the whole experience and your own costs before deciding how to compete.

“I completed SWOT, so my idea is validated.” A framework gives you a place to put questions. Real observations, customer conversations and a small delivery test help answer them.

Check your understanding: A worker packs lunch at home. Is that choice irrelevant because nobody sells them lunch? Suggested answer: No. Packing lunch is a substitute for the purchase Maya hopes to earn. She needs to learn why that worker chooses it before claiming her preorder service is better.

Optional watching

The recommendations are provisional. Original-page metadata and descriptions were checked 27 September 2026, but full content, duration, English captions and UK playback still need checking before publication. If you want a comparison-specific alternative, Learn With Shopify's competitor-analysis video is available, though its description includes substantial product promotion. The written article does not require any video.

Continue learning

The next planned chapter is Set a marketing goal you can actually measure. A public link can be added when that chapter exists. For an accessible external guide, read Business.gov.uk on testing an idea and understanding competition. For textbook depth, see OpenStax on internal and external influences (Gomez Albrecht, Green and Hoffman, 2023a), and the original Five Forces article (Porter, 2008).

References

Business.gov.uk (no date) Testing and validating your business idea. Available at: https://www.business.gov.uk/support/ideas-planning-strategy/testing-and-validating-your-business-idea/ (Accessed: 27 September 2026).

Gomez Albrecht, M., Green, M. and Hoffman, L. (2023a) Principles of Marketing, section 1.3. OpenStax. Available at: https://openstax.org/books/principles-marketing/pages/1-3-factors-comprising-and-affecting-the-marketing-environment (Accessed: 27 September 2026).

Gomez Albrecht, M., Green, M. and Hoffman, L. (2023b) Principles of Marketing, section 2.2. OpenStax. Available at: https://openstax.org/books/principles-marketing/pages/2-2-the-role-of-marketing-in-the-strategic-planning-process (Accessed: 27 September 2026).

Harvard Business School Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness (no date) The Five Forces. Available at: https://www.isc.hbs.edu/strategy/business-strategy/Pages/the-five-forces.aspx (Accessed: 27 September 2026).

Porter, M.E. (2008) 'The five competitive forces that shape strategy', Harvard Business Review, January. Available at: https://hbr.org/2008/01/the-five-competitive-forces-that-shape-strategy (Accessed: 27 September 2026).